Anthonys Pizzeria and Deli Wallingford Restaurant in (2024)

The service and food are excellent.

They charge full price for topping on half the pizza

We ordered a few pies from here the other nite. One was Anthony's Special and a Veggy. Both were delicious. The crust was perfectly done. Everything was great. Will be ordering again soon.

Hands down the best hidden sandwich shop in wallingford!! Staff is super friendly and food is fantastic. So good it may of become a staple weekly spot when I need a quick meal and don't have time to cook. Everything on the menu is a worldly experience. Highly highly recommend. And don't skimp out, get a garlic knot on the side!!!

Definitely one of the top 2 pizza places in Wallingford - closest to a new have style that I’ve had.

The food is great. But evertime I order, something It's wrong. It's on my receipt of "no tomatoes, no onion" etc. It's like they bever even look at that. Pizza is always wrong if any special requestsUpdate, went again. I paid for 3 1 liter sodas, they said it was only 2, and they only had 2 flavors, none of what I wanted. Ordered the turkey wrap with "cranberry aioli". I asked for extra on the side and it is canned cranberry sauce, not sure where the "aoli is". Ordered the bold bbq wings, thinking it was something different. Just plain Ole bbq, nothing special. Not a fan

Great place for something quick to eat. Got some sandwiches which were delicious, staff was friendly and service was quick

2nd time at Anthony’s and both times were awesome great job !!! Will be ordering here often !!

FINALLY a REAL New Haven pie in Wallingford, and it is real New Haven APIZZA. I can't say who for the sake of anonymnimaty, but the owner worked for one of the best in New Haven for years. Thier Pizza is great. The crust is full on thin with the "Bite" that makes it appiza . Done in an electic oven that he heats up to the needed temperature to get it that way. All their ingredients are very top grade.They have artisnal sandwiches , regular subs, some dinners, and deserts. Plus slices of apizza to go. They have a location in Cheshire on Rt 10 that is the same thing. Please frequent and try these places out. You won't be disappointed.

One of the best sandwich shops in Wallingford

I ordered my second Eggplant Parm stuffed bread and it was as delicious as the first one! I didn't measure it but it was in a large pizza box and took up corner to corner diagonally. It took me 4 nights to eat every bite. For the price you can't beat it!

First time takeout order.Meatball sub.Tuna sub.The meatball was excellent.The tuna w as good.The sub rolls were some of the best. Fresh.Highly recomend.

Exelent service, delicious food.

Best chicken bacon ranch pizza I've ever had.Staff is always super quick and getting orders perfect .

First time trying Anthony’s, we ordered a variety of items and they were all excellent. Steak and cheese grinder was great, same with Chicken Parm sandwich. Pizza was awesome. Loaded fries and Curley shrimp apps were both very good. Needless to say we will be back

This spot has the best food in Wallingford! Pizza here is amazing!

Quality New Haven style pie. I ordered a slice and it was below their credit card limit. They let me have it for free and told me to pay them back later. Good service.

"New Haven" in Wallingford! EXCEPTIONAL pizza! 10/10Stuffed breads ..... Delicious!ETC ETC ETC.....

So-so pizza, skimpy on toppings and pie was cold.

The best chicken cutlet I have had in YEARS! Their garlic knots are also amazing.

It’s our go-to spot . Their salads and pizzas are all delicious. And if you haven’t tried their cookies, you absolutely must! Highly recommend!!

The food was delicious. Both myself and my S/O had subs. Great portion size and the bread was soooo good.

Muy buena la atencion al cliente, muy Rica y deliciosa la pizza y los aperitivos 🍪🥗🍕🍰 🙂🙂

Una excelente calidad en pizzas calzones y stufed bread y los garlics knocks una delicia lo recomiendo bien

The best pizza in town. Proper ct pizza. New haven style pizza, thin and well done. Burnt crust and flavorful. The true test to see if pizza is good is if you eat the crust, and they do it perfectly! Also sell slices which is convenient, just stay away from the desserts if you are watching your weight. Great place!!!

Great food friendly service best sandwiches around try the gluten free wraps you won’t be disappointed!!!

Some of the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Definitely recommend